Tuesday, 23 June 2020

Personal Representatives – Notice Obligations

By Lydia Roseman, Student-at-Law


This post seeks to answer the following questions: who must a personal representative[i] give notice to? When must notice be given? What must be included in that notice?

There are a number of groups of people that may be entitled to notice before a personal representative distributes the assets of an estate. These notice requirements arise in a number of different pieces of Alberta legislation meaning it can be challenging to figure out exactly who you, as personal representative, must give notice to.

Exactly who is entitled to notice, and what the notice looks like, can also vary depending on whether you are acting with or without a grant. When the personal representative applies for a grant of probate or administration, there are strict rules governing the form of notice provided to the interested parties.

A personal representative may be acting without a grant of probate or administration in a couple situations. For example, if the deceased held all their assets jointly with another person, such as their spouse, it may be that all their assets automatically transferred to that other person. In that case, there may be no assets to administer and therefore no need for a court order formally granting the representative the authority to deal with assets. If all of the assets are held in cash or in bank accounts in fairly small denominations, again the personal representative may be able to access and distribute those assets without a grant (the bank may, however, require a bond of indemnity before they release the funds).

Where, however, you are dealing with an organization that requires a formal authorization to access the assets, for example the land titles office for real property, you will need a grant of probate or administration.

Below, this article addresses each group of people that may be entitled to notice and what that notice will look like, with or without a grant. As a starting point, notice must generally be given to anyone who is a beneficiary or who may have rights under the Wills and Succession Act (WSA) or the Family Property Act (FPA) (formerly known as the Matrimonial Property Act).

Following that is a discussion of a couple of special cases that may further complicate the notice requirements. The post ends with a discussion of the potential consequences on a personal representative of non-compliance.

Beneficiaries

            No Grant

Anyone who is entitled to a specific gift or a share of the residue of the estate is a beneficiary and must be given notice. This notice must be given even if there are no assets in the estate.
The current notice requirements state that the notice must:
1.     Identify the deceased.
2.     Provide the name and contact information of the personal representative.
3.     Describe the gift left to the beneficiary in the will or the applicable provisions of the WSA or Intestate Succession Act.
4.     Provide the date of the testator’s[ii] will.
5.     If the beneficiary is a residual beneficiary, provide a copy of the will.
6.     State that any gift is subject to the prior payment of the testator’s debt.

The notice may be given using the Court’s Form NGA 1. While the form of notice is flexible when acting without a grant, we recommend using the Court’s recommended forms as a starting point. Using these standard forms will save time and help ensure you provide the required information to the individual.

            Grant

All the beneficiaries under the will must be identified on form NC 6 which is included in the application for the grant of probate or administration with will annexed. The correct form of notice to be given to those beneficiaries will depend on what the beneficiary is receiving under the will.
If an individual is entitled to a specific gift, such as a piece of property, notice is given in Form NC 20. This notice includes a description of the specific gift to the beneficiary. If the specific gift is no longer within the estate, for example if the piece of property was sold prior to the testator’s death, then the beneficiary does not need to be notified. You will, however, need to make a note in the grant application that the gift no longer exists.

If the beneficiary is entitled to a share in the residue of the estate, use Form NC 19 instead. The main difference is that this form requires that you attach a copy of the application for the grant, including a copy of the entire will and a list of the estate’s assets and debts. The reason that a residual beneficiary is entitled to a copy of the will and the list of assets and debts is because they need to have enough information to know what their “residual gift” actually includes.

If there is no will, that is the deceased died intestate, you must still give notice to the “heirs” of the estate. This notice is completed via Form NC 21. The personal representative must identify the share of the estate that will be distributed to the heir under the WSA. In this situation, we suggest that you obtain legal advice to help you determine who the heirs are and what they are entitled to.

Spouses and Adult Interdependent Partners

            No Grant

Notice to a spouse or adult interdependent partner (AIP) will usually be provided under the beneficiary section above. However, there may be additional information that must be provided. If the spouse or AIP is not the sole beneficiary under the will, notice must be given to the individual of his or her rights under the WSA and FPA. This essentially provides notice to the spouse or AIP that there is a possibility they may have a claim to more of the testator’s estate. Forms NGA 2 and NGA 3 can be used for this notice.

If the spouse or AIP is a dependent or represented adult, instead send the notice to the individual’s trustee or attorney using Form NGA 4.

            Grant

As above when acting without a grant, if the spouse or AIP is not the sole beneficiary under the will, there are additional notice requirements. The applicant for the grant must serve on the individual a copy of the application for the grant, Form NC 23 outlining their rights under the WSA, and Form NC 22 outlining their rights under the FPA.

Where the spouse or AIP is a dependent or represented adult, the notice must be served upon the attorney or trustee, still using Forms NC 22 and NC 23.

Children

            No Grant

A child of the testator is not automatically entitled to notice. Only a child who meets the definition of a “family member” must be notified. Children born inside and outside the marriage are treated the same. A child will qualify as a “family member” if he or she is:
·       under 18 years of age (including in the womb);
·       over 18 and unable to earn a livelihood by reason of mental or physical disability; or
·       between 18 and 22 and a student under his parents’ charge.

Where a child of the testator falls into one of these categories, notice must be provided to the child referring them to their rights under the WSA. This notice may be in Form NGA 2.

This notice will instead be served on the child’s guardian if he or she is a minor, or on the child’s attorney or trustee if he or she is unable to earn a livelihood due to mental disability. In these cases, additional notice must also be provided which can be in Form NGA 4. Where the child is a minor, notice must also be served on the Public Trustee and can be in Form NGA 4. Note that the notices in both Form NGA 4 and NGA 2 must include a copy of the will.

            Grant

The same definition of “child” applies where the personal representative applies for a grant; therefore, the same categories of children are entitled to notice. Those children (or their guardians, trustees, or attorneys) must be given notice of their rights under the WSA and a copy of their grant application.

Where the child is under 18 (including in the womb), the notice is given to both the Public Trustee (Form NC 24.1) and the child’s guardian (Form NC 24). If the child is over 18 and unable to earn a livelihood by reason of physical disability, or falls into the student category, Form NC 24 is served directly on the child. Finally, if the child is over 18 but unable to earn a livelihood due to mental disability, Form NC 24 must be served on the child’s attorney and/or trustee.

Grandchildren and Great-Grandchildren

            No Grant

If the deceased stood in the place of a parent to a grandchild or great-grandchild who was a minor on the date of death, notice must be sent to the guardian of the grandchild or great-grandchild (Form NGA 2) and the Public Trustee (Form NGA 4).

            Grant

If the testator had a grandchild or great-grandchild in the position described above, notice must be served on the guardian of the grandchild or great-grandchild (Form NC 24) and on the Public Trustee (Form NC 24.1).

Special Cases

            Separated AIP or separated or divorced spouse

If a spouse was separated from the deceased but not yet divorced, that spouse is still entitled to the notice as described above.

If an AIP recently separated from the deceased, or a spouse recently divorced the deceased, that individual may still be entitled to notice. A surviving ex-spouse or former AIP is entitled to notice of their rights under the FPA so long as the individual could have brought a family property division application immediately before the deceased passed. These timelines can be quite complicated but generally this means that if the deceased divorced a spouse in the last two years, or lived with an AIP in the last 3 years, that individual may be entitled to notice.

Also note that it is possible for a testator to have both a spouse and an AIP, or two spouses, falling within the notice provisions. This could occur, for example, where a spouse and the deceased were separated and the deceased lived with an AIP, or where the deceased was divorced and remarried within two years of his or her death. When this type of situation occurs, notice must be served on both individuals.

If you are handling an estate with former spouses or AIPs, we recommend seeking legal advice to ensure you properly fulfill your obligations to these individuals.

            What if an individual entitled to notice is deceased?

For example, if a beneficiary in the will is deceased, but the gift has not lapsed, that beneficiary may still be entitled to notice. The notice must generally be provided to the personal representative of the estate, either appointed or listed in the will.

If there is a will but no personal representative, consider contacting the Public Trustee to see if it would be willing to apply for a grant of administration or act as administrator for the deceased beneficiary. If the deceased beneficiary did not have a will but you know who the heirs are under intestacy rules, it is a good idea to give notice to the beneficiary’s heirs.

In this situation, you can also apply to the Court for direction on how you should proceed.

            What if an individual owed notice is missing?

You cannot serve notice on an individual if you cannot find them. What happens then? The personal representative must make all efforts to find the individual. If the individual cannot be found, the personal representative must apply to declare the person missing under the Public Trustee Act. Once the individual is declared missing, any required notice must be sent to the Public Trustee.

When should you give notice?

There is no specific legislated timeline for sending notice to beneficiaries, spouses, and other family members mentioned above. That being said, the personal representative cannot obtain a grant of probate or administration, or distribute the assets of the estate, until notice has been given.

We recommend providing notice as soon as possible. To do so, the personal representative must have located the will (if it exists), assessed the testator’s assets and debts, and identified all the beneficiaries and family members. If the personal representative will be applying for a grant, the application will need to be completed so that a copy can be included in the notices. Once these steps are complete, the notices should be sent.

How should you give notice?

A personal representative applying for a grant must be able to prove that notice was served on the required parties (or their lawyers). This is easiest to do by using registered mail. This will provide confirmation of delivery that can readily be provided to the Court. You can also personally serve someone, that is hand deliver to them yourself, and then swear that you did so in an affidavit.

Finally, the party required to be served can acknowledge their receipt of the documents. When applying for a grant, this acknowledgement can be contained in Form NC 2 or on the bottom of the notice.

When acting without a grant, it is a good idea to still follow one of these steps so that you are able to prove service if you ever need to in the future.

Effect of Non-Compliance

If a personal representative fails to provide the required notice, the Court has the discretion to:
·       order the personal representative to provide the notice;
·       impose conditions on the personal representative;
·       remove the personal representative;
·       revoke a grant; and
·       make any other order it considers appropriate.

Importantly, personal representatives are also considered to be trustees within Alberta’s Trustee Act and are in a fiduciary relationship with the beneficiaries. Breaches of fiduciary obligations can lead to serious, personal consequences.

If you are ever in doubt about the required notices, consider retaining a lawyer. The estate will usually pay the legal fees associated with this advice.

Our Wills & Estates team would be happy to help you with any issues that may arise during your time as a personal representative.


[i] For ease of reading, I use the term personal representative and do not differentiate between an executor and an administrator. In general terms, the personal representative named in a will is an executor. When there is no valid will or where the will fails to name a personal representative, the acting personal representative is called an administrator.

[ii] A testator is a person who has written and executed a will.

Friday, 29 May 2020

85 is the New 71 – The Advanced Life Deferred Annuity

By Lydia Roseman, Student-at-Law and Michelle Fong

While the proposed legislation states that the ALDA will be deemed to have come into effect on January 1, 2020, some industry professionals suspect that it will not come into force until next year. We will update this article once such legislation is enacted.

Budget 2019 proposed a new type of annuity, the advanced life deferred annuity (ALDA), to provide greater flexibility to Canadians managing their retirement savings.

When individuals contribute to registered plans, such as a registered retirement savings plan (RRSP), the amounts contributed are tax-deferred until the funds are withdrawn out from the plan. Generally, these are considered “retirement savings” because it is expected that you do not withdraw them until after you have retired. The benefit of waiting is that people are usually in a lower tax bracket after retirement. However, not everyone wants to start withdrawing funds (and being taxed on such funds) immediately after retirement.

The most common example is an RRSP. An RRSP “expires” in the year that the owner turns 71. The owner’s options are to:
·       withdraw all the funds from the RRSP;
·       convert it to a registered retirement income fund (RRIF); or
·       use the funds to buy some other annuity.

A full withdrawal means all the funds are included in the owner’s taxable income. Alternatively, at the moment, an RRIF and most other annuities purchased using registered funds will generally require minimum annual withdrawals (taxable) by you by the end of the year you turn 71. The proposed ALDA (a new annuity) will instead allow you to defer the start of withdrawals until the end of the year you turn 85.

This change can mean a valuable tax deferral for individuals who do not need or want to draw down their registered funds between the ages of 71 and 85. Those individuals can continue to hold some of these funds tax free for an additional 14 years.

The ALDA is also a great tool for longevity planning. By purchasing an ALDA, you ensure that there are funds available to support you in your (much) later years.

Things to Know

The ALDA is currently designed to have come into effect on January 1, 2020.* It will be available for purchase under an RRSP, RRIF, deferred profit sharing plan, pooled registered pension plan (PRPP), or a defined contribution registered pension plan (RPP). An ALDA will also be a “qualified investment” for a trust governed by an RRSP or RRIF.

There are, however, a couple limits on the amount of an ALDA that an individual can purchase. There is a lifetime dollar limit of $150,000 (indexed to inflation) and a lifetime limit of 25% of any particular qualifying plan.

These limits apply at the time of purchase meaning that any subsequent devaluation of assets held by a plan and corresponding reduction in the lifetime ALDA limit will not lead to a surrender of the excess amount. That means it is best to purchase an ALDA when the assets in your qualifying plan are at their peak value to ensure maximum contribution to the ALDA and therefore maximum tax deferral.

The value of the ALDA will be excluded in calculating the minimum amount that must be withdrawn in a year from a RRIF, PRPP or defined contribution RPP.

The tax benefits are two-fold. First, you may defer the taxes of up to 25% or $150,000 of your funds held in a registered plan until you are 85. Second, by excluding the value of the ALDA from the RRIF, PRPP, or defined contribution RPP minimum calculation, the regular payments out of these funds/plans will therefore be lower meaning even more tax savings between the ages of 71 and 85.

Non-Compliance

Any purchases of ALDA contracts beyond an individual’s limit will attract a tax of 1% per month on the excess amount. However, all or a portion of this penalty may be waived if the purchaser establishes that the overcontribution was a reasonable error and the excess amount is repaid to the registered fund it was taken from by the end of the following year.

A non-compliant ALDA contract will be considered a non-qualifying annuity purchase or a non-qualified investment for tax purposes. This may mean an immediate tax liability.

It is very important that you receive advice and purchase an ALDA through an appropriate institution.

Conclusion

The ALDA is a great new tool for tax deferral and longevity planning. If done right, it can mean substantial tax reduction between your 71st and 85th years. But, if done wrong, it may lead to immediate negative tax consequences.

Our Wills & Estates team would be happy to help you incorporate the use of an ALDA into your succession plan and estate plan. Please contact our office.

*The legislation implementing the ALDA has not yet been enacted. As drafted, the changes will be deemed to have come into force on January 1, 2020.

Tuesday, 26 May 2020

Timeline of an Estate: Tax and Other Considerations

by Michelle Fong


Being entrusted to be an Executor is an honour – it means that the deceased believes that you are the best suited person to manage and care for their estate. However, the position also comes with legal responsibilities and liabilities. The “job” of an Executor can last from a year or more, with or without contentious beneficiaries.

The Executor has many duties. This article focuses the notable deadlines and timelines. The “Administering the Estate” timeline focuses on the Grant of Probate process (if there is no Will, it is called a Grant of Administration). The “Tax” timeline focuses on what needs to be done at what point to alleviate the tax burden of the estate.

ESTATE ADMINISTRATION TIMELINE

Broadly speaking, in administering an estate, the Executor’s role is to gather the assets of the estate, protect them, ensure debts are paid, then distribute the assets. It seems simple enough. However, there are certain events and their timing that should be considered.
1.   A Notice to Claimants may be published in the local newspaper. The Executor is responsible for ensuring debts of the estate are paid before they distribute the assets to the beneficiaries. This notice “starts the clock” for any claimants who are owed money from the estate – they must contact the Executor within 30 days and formalize their claim.  After the 30 days, the Executor can move forward with the estate without worrying about claimants coming out of the woodwork. The Executor can be held personally liable if they distribute the estate to beneficiaries before ensuring all debts are paid.
2.     Apply for a Grant of Probate (or Administration). There is no “deadline” for applying for a Grant of Probate (or Administration) but certain institutions may refuse to acknowledge an Executor’s authority until a Grant of Probate is obtained. This may make it difficult to deal with the estate assets and debts without a Grant of Probate.[1] It takes time to compile the information for an application for the Grant and, once it is submitted to the Court, it can take 4-5 months to be processed. This is also assuming that no one contests the application.
3.    Family Maintenance and Supports claims. After the Grant of Probate is obtained, a family member[2], as legislatively defined, will have 6 months from the date of the Grant to make a family maintenance and support claim from the Estate. The basis of the claim is that the deceased failed to make adequate provision for the proper maintenance and support of the family member. If the Executor distributes the estate assets prior to this 6-month deadline (or prior to the matter being settled, if a claim is lodged), then the Executor will be personally liable to the family member for the estate assets they are found to be entitled to.
4.  Final Clearance Certificate. The Executor is responsible for ensuring debts of the estate are paid before they distribute the assets to the beneficiaries. One major debt of the estate is tax. After filing the terminal tax return and receiving the Notice of Assessment, the Executor should pay taxes owed and then apply for a final Clearance Certificate (if the Estate is designated as a graduated rate estate (see below), then the final Clearance Certificate is applied for when the Estate is almost ready to distribute). This Certificate is the CRA’s confirmation that all taxes have been paid. The Certificate may take 1 to 1.5 years to be issued. If the Executor distributes the estate prematurely, they will be personally liable for any taxes that are found still owing. It is recommended to wait until after the receipt of the final Clearance Certificate before distributing assets to beneficiaries. For more info, see here.
5.  Accounting.  Accounting is a very important task.  The Executor must provide an accounting to the beneficiaries every two years of their management of the Estate assets.  The law requires this accounting to take a particular form, so it is best to seek advice from experienced counsel. The Executor can have the accounting approved by the beneficiaries or by the Court.  By seeking this approval, the Executor’s liability for their management of the Estate assets during the accounting period is relieved.   
6.    Executor compensation. Executor compensation is a priority claim against the Estate and may be paid in priority to certain other debts.  Unless the Will expressly provides for the amount of executor compensation, compensation may not be taken absent beneficiary or Court approval. 
7.    Distribution to Beneficiaries – Once all of the debts of the Estate have been paid and the accounting approved, either by the beneficiaries or the Court, a distribution to the beneficiaries can occur. 

TAX TIMELINES

First and foremost, the Executor should hire a good accountant. Depending on the complexity of the estate, a tax lawyer may also need to be brought on. As mentioned above, taxes are usually owed by the Estate. This is because, for one, there is a deemed disposition of all capital property upon death (capital gains taxes incurred) and, second, any income of the deceased in the year of death will also attract tax (e.g. interest income, employment income, etc.).

Filing return

Terminal tax return (Final income tax return)

If the deceased died on or before October 31st, then the terminal tax return is due April 30th of the following year. (Or, June 30th if the deceased was self-employed).

If the deceased died after October 31st, then the terminal tax return is due 6 months after the death.

Other tax returns

Any returns that the deceased was responsible for, such as corporate tax returns or trust returns, may become the responsibility of the Executor if there are no other directors of the corporation, or other trustees of the trust. Be aware that:
·  A corporation’s T2 return filing deadline is 6 months after its tax year-end (but corporate taxes may be due 2 or 3 months after tax year-end). 
·   A trust’s T3 return filing deadline is 3 months after its tax year-end. Taxes are due at the same time.

Elective returns

In addition to the regular terminal tax return filed for the deceased, other optional returns can be filed. The benefits of filing multiple returns is, generally, certain tax credits can be claimed on each return (duplicating tax credits) and the income in each return will be subject to graduated rates (duplicating the lower tax rates).
1.  Rights or things return. Rights or things relate to income that the deceased was entitled to but had not yet been paid. For example, declared but unpaid dividends, or work in progress amounts. This return is due 1 year after death or 90 days after the Notice of Assessment for the terminal return, whichever is later.
2.     Income return from proprietor (business) or partner.  If the deceased died after the end of the business's fiscal period but before the calendar year-end (in which the fiscal period ended), you can file an optional return for the deceased. This return is due at the same time as the terminal tax return.
3.   Graduated Rate Estate (GRE) return. Discussed below. To be treated as a GRE, the Executor must designate the estate to be a GRE in a T3 trust return. The first GRE return is due at the same time as the terminal tax return. Subsequent returns are due in accordance with the T3 deadlines (3 months after tax year-end). 

For more information on optional returns, see the CRA site here.

Graduated Rate Estate

An estate is considered a trust for tax purposes. Subject to certain exceptions, trusts are taxed at the highest marginal rate. However, a GRE allows the estate to be taxed at graduated rates instead and they have more flexible donation rules. Also, in order to avail the estate to certain tax elections and options, the shares of private corporation must be held by a GRE (discussed below).

An estate must be designated as a GRE. In order to qualify as a GRE, the following criteria must be satisfied during the entire duration of the GRE:
                 i.          the estate arose on and as a consequence of the individual’s death no more than 36 months after the death;
               ii.          the estate is at that time a testamentary trust;
             iii.          the deceased’s Social Insurance Number is provided in the estate’s Trust Return for each taxation year of the estate during the 36-month period after the death of the deceased;
              iv.          the estate designates itself as GRE of the individual in its Trust Return (GRE Return) for tax year of death; and
                v.          no other estate designates itself as the GRE of the deceased.[3]

A GRE, and its preferential tax treatment, will only last up to 36 months from death. It can be terminated earlier if it distributes all assets, or if the estate no longer satisfies all the above requirements.

Corporations: Options to avoid double taxation

If the deceased owned shares in a private corporation at death, then there may be double taxation (tax at the deemed disposition at death, and tax upon extracting the funds from the corporation to pay the beneficiaries). There are certain strategies to avoid this double taxation.  The two most common are:
1.  Loss Carryback 164 Election. The deemed disposition at death will increase the adjusted cost base of the shares to fair market value. The Estate (GRE) then redeems the shares in the corporation, creating a deemed dividend and a capital loss. This capital loss is then carried back to net against the capital gain at death. The 164 election to carryback the capital loss must be included on the terminal return, meaning this option must be completed within 1 year after death.
2.    Pipeline (post-mortem). A pipeline requires a new corporation to be created (NewCo) in addition to the private corporation already owned by the deceased (PrivCo). The NewCo will acquire the shares of the PrivCo from the Estate (GRE) in exchange for a promissory note or preferred shares. Later on, NewCo will then use the assets originally in PrivCo to pay off the promissory note.  The is no “deadline” for this transaction but there is a timeline. The NewCo and PrivCo must exist for at least 1 year (we recommend longer, such as 3 years). The assets should not be distributed to the beneficiaries until after the 1-3-year period. Therefore, it is better to start this process sooner than later.

Both options are complex and carry risks and benefits. The above explanations are very generalized overviews. The risk of double taxation, and the complexity associated with avoiding it, means a tax practitioner should always be consulted as soon as possible if an estate includes shares of a private corporation.

Rollovers: Spouse and Farm or Fishing Property

Upon death, the deceased is deemed to have disposed all his or her capital property at fair market value. This will often trigger tax for capital gains and recapture (if depreciable property).

However, there are two main exceptions where the property is deemed to be transferred at cost instead:
·      Rollover to a spouse, common-law partner, or qualified spousal trust. To qualify for this rollover, the property must vest indefeasibly in the spouse, common-law partner or trust within 36 months after death. The “default” rule is that the transfer will occur at cost if it qualifies (no election required) but the Executor may elect out of this default rule and the transfer will then occur at fair market value.
·      Rollover of farm or fishing property from parent to child. To qualify for this rollover, the property must be qualified farm and fishing property[4], the recipient child must be a Canadian resident immediately before the deceased died, the property must have transferred to the child as a consequence of the deceased’s death, and the property must vest indefeasibly in the child within 36-months after death. The “default” rule is that the transfer will occur at cost (no election required) but the Executor may elect to have the transfer occur at any value between cost and fair market value.

In both exceptions, it is possible for the Executor to elect for the transfer to occur not at cost. This is usually done to trigger capital gains tax which can then be offset with the deceased’s lifetime capital gains exemption. For the capital gains exemption to apply, the property must be eligible property and the deceased must still have a capital gains exemption balance at death.[5], [6]

CONCLUSION

Acting as Executor can be time-consuming, onerous and complicated. This article aims to highlight the deadlines that must be met and to demonstrate that administering an Estate can take a long time, even for the most organized. Therefore, it is generally better to start earlier than later.

The McLennan Ross Wills & Estates Group and Tax Group would be happy to assist you in dealing with your Executor’s duties as well as the various tax issues that may apply to the estate. Please contact our office.


[1] A Grant of Probate will usually be required for dealing with bank accounts exceeding a certain amount and for any land transfers.
[2] Family members include spouses, adult interdependent partners, minor children and dependent adult children.
[3] This means that any testamentary trusts or insurance trusts also resulting from the death of the deceased cannot be designated as a GRE. There can only be one GRE per deceased person.
[4] There are certain requirements to qualify as farm and fishing property, such as the property must be used principally (50%+) for farming or fishing, and that the taxpayer (or certain family members) have been engaged actively and continuously in the farming or fishing. The requirements are quite technical and may be complex in their application, so we recommend a tax practitioner confirm the property qualifies before attempting to take advantage of this rollover.
[5] Note, paragraph 110.6(14)(g) of the Income Tax Act gives some relief. So long as the relevant corporation met the test for “small business corporation” at any time in the preceding 12-months prior to death, then the shares are deemed to be “qualified small business corporation shares”.  The definition of “small business corporation” is under subsection 248(1) and requires the corporation to be a Canadian-controlled private corporation with certain criteria met. Again, the requirements are quite technical and may be complex in their application, so we recommend a tax practitioner confirm the property qualifies before attempting to take advantage of the exemption.
[6] Note, claiming certain losses will decrease the balance of the lifetime capital gains exemption of a person.

Monday, 25 May 2020

New Trust Reporting Requirements: It’s Almost Time

By Lydia Roseman, Student-at-Law and MaryAnne Loney

Budget 2018 announced, and Budget 2019 confirmed, that trust reporting requirements are changing in 2021. While it may have felt far away at the time, 2021 is now almost upon us. If they have not already, it is time for trustees to start thinking about the implications of these changes. They need to ask themselves, are the benefits of a trust worth the effort and risks?

The new reporting requirements

The proposed changes primarily affect express trusts, that is trusts created by specific intent, usually in writing. As it stands right now, these trusts are generally only required to file if certain circumstances arise during the taxation year, for example if the trust earns income, disposes of capital property, or makes distributions to beneficiaries. In other words, if nothing changes for the trust then nothing is reported. 

Starting in 2021, except for a few specifically exempted types of trusts (such as mutual fund trusts or trusts that qualify as registered charities), express trusts resident in Canada must:

  1. file income tax returns annually in the form of a T3 Trust Income Tax and Information Return (T3);
  2. report all the settlors, trustees and beneficiaries of the trust; and
  3. identify any persons who exert control over the trustee’s decisions concerning income and capital (“protectors”).

This new information will be filed as a new schedule (yet to be released) with the T3. The information reported on the settlors, trustees and beneficiaries includes each individual’s taxation identification number (usually their social insurance number), birth date, address and jurisdictions of residence.

Increased risks associated with the new reporting requirements

Failing to comply with these new requirements can mean harsh penalties. Filings that are late or fail to provide the required additional information are penalized $25 a day for each day the filing is late, from a minimum of $100 to a maximum of $2,500. Additionally, if the failure was made knowingly, or due to gross negligence, an additional penalty of 5% of the maximum value of the trust property (minimum $2,500 penalty) will apply. 

Collecting this information may be an extremely onerous process, especially where there is a broad group of beneficiaries, so consider starting the process sooner rather than later.

Further, this change could have much further reaching implications.

Once the CRA has this information, a whole new set of other potential taxation issues arise. For example, the increased availability of beneficial ownership information of corporations means the CRA can crack down on related shareholders and associated corporations. Theoretically, beneficiaries of trusts that they did not even know existed could now be facing major tax implications from association rules. 

As a result, this could impact a trustee’s obligation to disclose the existence of a trust to beneficiaries.

In Valard Construction Ltd. v. Bird Construction Co, 2018 SCC 8, the Supreme Court held that a trustee’s fiduciary duty includes an obligation to disclose the existence of a trust to a beneficiary wherever a beneficiary would be unreasonably disadvantaged not to be informed of its existence. While this case arose in the commercial context, the case has already been cited for its general principles of trust law in other contexts.

If a court were to hold that unforeseen tax consequences to a beneficiary taxpayer were an unreasonable disadvantage due to not being informed of the existence of a trust, the trustee could be personally liable for a breach of its fiduciary duty. 

Trustees should, therefore, consider disclosing the existence of trusts now to any beneficiaries, including discretionary beneficiaries, that are currently unaware they are beneficiaries.

Conclusion

Given the above, trustees should consider whether it would be preferable to wind up their trusts. There are many reasons, including tax reasons, why parties will continue to use trusts. However, many of the tax advantages of using trusts have been eliminated over the last several years and family circumstances will have changed. Added with the hassle and risks associated with the new reporting requirements, some trusts settled several years ago may no longer make sense.

These conversations must happen soon so restructuring can be completed before the next taxation year begins.

The lawyers from the Wills and Estates Group would be happy to assist you in determining whether it makes sense to continue any trusts and/or assist with any reorganization or wind-up which may be advisable.